All Comparisons

SEO vs Google Ads: Where Should You Invest?

Both drive leads—but they work very differently. Here's how to choose.

Should you invest in SEO, Google Ads, or both?

TL;DR

SEO builds compounding traffic you own — but takes 3-6 months. Google Ads delivers leads immediately — but stops when you stop paying. The smartest play: run ads for cash flow while SEO builds momentum, then let organic take over the heavy lifting.

Side-by-side comparison

Category
SEO (Organic Search)
Google Ads (PPC)
Time to First Lead
3-6 months
Days after launch
Cost Structure
Monthly retainer, no per-click fees
Pay per click + management fee
Long-Term Value
Compounds — traffic grows over time
Stops when budget stops
Trust Factor
Higher — 70% of users skip ads
Lower — labeled as sponsored
Control
Less — Google decides rankings
More — you set budgets and targeting
Best For
Long-term growth and lower CPL
Immediate leads and seasonal pushes

SEO (Organic Search)

Pros

  • Compounds over time—builds equity
  • Higher trust factor (people skip ads)
  • No per-click costs
  • Targets the entire customer journey
  • 3x higher conversion rate vs paid

Cons

  • Takes 3-6 months to see significant results
  • Requires ongoing content and optimization
  • Algorithm changes can impact rankings
  • Competitive markets are harder to crack

Best For

Businesses playing the long game who want sustainable, compounding traffic.

Google Ads (PPC)

Pros

  • Immediate visibility—ads go live in days
  • Precise targeting and control
  • Easy to test and optimize quickly
  • Scalable with budget
  • Great for new markets or seasonal pushes

Cons

  • Costs money for every click
  • Results stop when you stop paying
  • Increasing competition raises costs
  • Requires ongoing management

Best For

Businesses that need leads now, are launching new services, or have seasonal demand.

The answer: Start with ads, build SEO alongside

Run Google Ads for immediate leads while investing in SEO for the long term. As SEO gains traction, you can reduce ad spend—or keep both running for maximum coverage.

Ads give you cash flow while SEO builds momentum
SEO insights improve your ad targeting (and vice versa)
Owning both paid and organic spots dominates the search page
SEO eventually reduces your cost per lead dramatically

Common questions

For local service businesses, $1,000-$3,000/month is a solid starting point. Enough to gather data and generate leads, but not so much that mistakes are costly.

You'll see movement in 60-90 days, meaningful traffic in 4-6 months, and full potential in 12+ months. It's a marathon, not a sprint—but the finish line is worth it.

The basics, sure — claim your Google Business Profile, ask for reviews, write service pages. But that's table stakes. Technical SEO, local link building, and competing against businesses that already have an agency behind them? That's where DIY hits a wall.

For most service trades, $30-$75 per lead through Google Ads depending on your market. SEO leads cost less over time — once you rank, each lead is essentially free. The key is tracking it. Every call, every form submission, every dollar — traced to the campaign that produced it. If you can't see your cost per lead in real time, you're guessing.

If budget allows, yes. Running both means you dominate the search results page — your ad at the top and your organic listing below. Data from your ads (which keywords convert) also improves your SEO targeting. Most of our clients start with ads for immediate leads, then layer in SEO for long-term growth.

Ready to make the right choice?

Let's talk about what makes sense for your specific situation. No pressure, just honest advice.

SEO vs PPC: Which Drives More Leads?