All Comparisons

Marketing Agency vs DIY: Which is Right for Your Business?

An honest breakdown of when to hire help and when to do it yourself

Should you hire an agency or handle marketing yourself?

TL;DR

DIY marketing costs less upfront but eats your billable hours and compounds mistakes. An agency costs $2,000-$5,000/month but delivers faster results with proven systems. If your time is worth more than the agency fee, the math favors hiring help.

Side-by-side comparison

Category
DIY Marketing
Marketing Agency
Monthly Cost
$0-$500 (tools + time)
$2,000-$5,000/month
Time Investment
10-20+ hours/month of your time
2-4 hours/month for check-ins
Speed to Results
Slow — learning curve adds months
Faster — proven systems from day one
Expertise Level
Limited to what you can learn
Full team: SEO, ads, design, content
Risk of Mistakes
High — bad SEO or wasted ad spend
Low — tested strategies
Scalability
Caps out at your bandwidth
Scales with your goals

DIY Marketing

Pros

  • Lower upfront cost
  • Full control over messaging
  • Learn valuable skills
  • No communication delays
  • You know your customers better than anyone

Cons

  • Steep learning curve
  • Time away from billable work
  • Often slower results
  • Easy to make costly mistakes
  • Hard to stay current with best practices

Best For

Brand new businesses with more time than money, or owners who genuinely enjoy marketing.

Marketing Agency

Pros

  • Faster, proven results from day one
  • Full team of specialists vs learning everything yourself
  • Free up your time for revenue work
  • Real-time dashboards — see every call, lead, and dollar spent
  • No contract means they have to perform to keep you

Cons

  • Monthly investment required
  • Need to find one that specializes in your industry
  • Bad agencies exist — look for transparency and no contracts

Best For

Established businesses where the owner's time is worth more than the agency fee.

The real question: What's your time worth?

If you bill $100+/hour and marketing takes 10+ hours/month to do well, the math is simple. An agency that costs $2,500/month but frees up 15 hours is actually saving you money — plus getting better results. The key is finding one with no contract and full transparency, so you can see exactly what your money is doing.

Most DIY marketers underestimate the time investment by 3-5x
A platform with real-time tracking eliminates the "is it working?" guesswork
The cost of mistakes (bad SEO, wasted ad spend) often exceeds agency fees
No contract means the agency has to earn your business every month — that's the accountability DIY can't match

Common questions

For service businesses, expect $2,000-$5,000/month for comprehensive marketing. Less than $2,000 usually means corners are being cut. More than $5,000 is typically for larger companies or aggressive growth.

Absolutely. Many business owners start DIY, learn enough to understand what good looks like, then hire an agency when their time becomes more valuable elsewhere.

Most of our clients have. The last one took the money, stopped answering, and left nothing to show for it. That's why we built a platform with full transparency — every call tracked, every dollar traced to a booked job. No contracts, no mystery invoices. You see everything and you can leave anytime.

A good trades-focused agency should show measurable progress within 90 days — more calls, more booked jobs, better Google visibility. If an agency can't tell you exactly how they'll move the needle, that's a red flag. We guarantee results in 90 days or we've failed, not you.

$2,000/month is a realistic starting point for local service businesses. It covers the essentials — SEO, Google Business optimization, review management, and basic ad campaigns. As revenue grows, scaling to $2,500-$3,000/month unlocks more aggressive strategies like paid ads and content marketing.

Ready to make the right choice?

Let's talk about what makes sense for your specific situation. No pressure, just honest advice.

Agency vs DIY Marketing Compared